August 5, 2025
Headlines

Rules Committee

Thirteen members waved a clipboard last week, and the U.S. House quit work before lunch.

Democrats on the House Rules Committee planned—again—to force a vote mandating full release of Jeffrey Epstein files. Chair Virginia Foxx and two GOP colleagues balked; casting a second “no” on transparency would be political napalm back home. They told Speaker Mike Johnson they would not report any rule.1

Johnson gathered leadership at 6 p.m. on July 22. The menu:

  • Forge ahead and watch the rule die on the floor (humiliating).
  • Water‑down amendment language—but Foxx warned it still lacked GOP votes.
  • Shut down the agenda, buy recess time for the White House to pre‑release documents.

The Speaker chose door #3. Two immigration bills vanished, Thursday votes were canceled, and members headed for airports. It was the second time in two years that a fractured GOP majority let a rule crisis stop the chamber—after the June 6 2023 Freedom Caucus rebellion that felled the first rule since 2002.2

Sponsor Break 

Glory Days Apparel — “Charlotte’s Premier Nostalgia Brand.” Flash a two‑inch Glory Days tattoo at 2202 Hawkins St. and snag a $50 gift card plus 20 % off forever. Retro ball‑card promo, secret‑menu drops, even lifetime discounts for brave ink. Tees softer than a Panthers bye week. Thanks, Glory Days, for bankrolling this caffeine habit! ☕️

Why It Matters to Charlotte

A stalled rule means stalled money. But when the committee loosens the tap, local riders can flow:

Bill & RuleNC‑Centric Amendments Allowed (would die under a closed rule)Source
H.R. 3935 FAA Re‑authorization — H.Res. 597 (structured, 18 Jul 2023)• #60 Rep. Kathy Manning – FAA partnerships with HBCUs/MSIs (NC A&T, Johnson C. Smith)• #61 Manning – 180‑day youth‑in‑aviation workforce report (Charlotte‑Meck Aviation Academy)• #87 Rep. David Rouzer – Pilot‑medical modernization task group (requested by CLT‑based biz‑aviation firms)• #88 Rouzer – Ban DOT purchase of PRC drones (CLT & Piedmont airport procurement)House Report 118‑147
H.R. 2670 FY 24 NDAA — H.Res. 582/583 (structured, 12‑13 Jul 2023)• #632 Rep. Richard Hudson – 2‑year semiconductor‑technician pilot at community colleges near silicon‑carbide fabs (Rowan‑Cabarrus + Wolfspeed corridor)• #641 Rep. Deborah Ross – $10 M CHIPS apprenticeships once fab utilization > 70 % (Triangle & Charlotte supplier base)House Report 118‑141

How the Rules Committee Works

  1. Gatekeeper Jurisdiction No major bill hits the floor without a “special rule” reported from Rules.3 The rule:
    • sets debate time,
    • lists which amendments are in order,
    • waives points of order (e.g., PAYGO, Budget Act).
  2. Membership Math 13 seats: 9 majority, 4 minority. Speakers stack loyalists; since 2023 three Freedom Caucus rebels hold veto leverage if they join Democrats.
  3. Types of Rules
    • Closed No floor amendments—favored when leadership fears poison pills.
    • Structured Specific amendments listed—lets whips cut deals. Example: H.Res. 597.
    • Open Any germane amendment—extinct birds; zero thus far in the 118th Congress.
    • Same‑Day / Martial‑Law Allows a rule to be adopted the same calendar day it’s reported—used for cliff‑edge deals.
  4. Workflow
    • Policy committee reports bill → sponsor files rule request.
    • Rules holds a hearing (majority decides who testifies).
    • Members submit amendments; majority counsel curates list.
    • Committee marks up the rule (majority always wins vote).
    • House debates the rule first; defeating it blocks the bill entirely.
  5. Minority Escape Hatches
    • Discharge Petition 218 signatures force a bill to the floor (rare; last success 2015 Export‑Import Bank).
    • Previous‑Question Defeat If five majority members side with minority, control of floor flips—last happened 1982.
  6. Self‑Executing Provisions Rule text can declare selected amendments “hereby adopted” once the rule passes—no separate vote.
  7. Historical Course Corrections
    • 1910 Cannon Revolt Progressives stripped Speaker Joseph Cannon of Rules chairmanship and created Calendar Wednesday & discharge petition.4
    • 1961 Rayburn Expansion Speaker Sam Rayburn added three liberals to outvote segregationist Chair Howard Smith, unlocking civil‑rights bills.5
    • 1979‑1995 Rise of “king‑of‑the‑hill” and “queen‑of‑the‑hill” rules to allow alternative budget plans without filibuster‑style chaos.6

Quick Hits

  • Activity Scorecard Through July 1 the 118th Congress had 211 special rules: 115 closed, 83 structured, 1 modified‑open, 0 open.7
  • Clock Management A closed rule on a 300‑page bill saves ∼6 hours of amendment time vs. a structured rule.
  • Same‑Day History First used for the 1979 Chrysler Loan Guarantee Act.
  • Emoji Quota 🚦—green light only if Rules says so.

See You Next Time

Next Thursday I’ll profile the Appropriations “Cardinals”—twelve chairs dividing a $1.7 T pie and why Mecklenburg’s school‑lunch lettuce depends on them. Until then, remember: process is policy, and the traffic cop never sleeps.

About the Author

I’m Jack Beckett, perennially caffeinated at Central Coffee. Find longer digs at News, Business, Housing, and Politics. Bookmark our election HQ — Poll Dance 2025 — for precinct‑level snark. DMs open on X (we call it Twix).

Fine print hides here: Privacy Policy • About Us • Terms of Service • Media • Contact Us

☕️ Until Congress invents another rule, I’ll keep refills coming.

Creative Commons License

© 2025 Strolling Ballantyne / The Charlotte Mercury
This article, “How the House Rules Committee Froze Congress — and Still Boosted Two NC Wins,” by Jack Beckett is licensed under CC BY‑ND 4.0.

“How the House Rules Committee Froze Congress — and Still Boosted Two NC Wins”
by Jack Beckett, The Charlotte Mercury (CC BY‑ND 4.0)

Footnotes

  1. [Politico, “The rule was going down,” Meredith Lee Hill & Hailey Fuchs, 24 Jul 2025] ↩
  2. [Washington Post, “Hard‑right Republicans foil McCarthy on floor vote,” 6 Jun 2023] ↩
  3. [House Rules Committee, “Special Rule Process” explainer] ↩
  4. [U.S. House History, “Cannon Revolt of 1910”] ↩
  5. [House Historical Highlights, “Rayburn Engineers 1961 Rules Committee Expansion”] ↩
  6. [CRS Report RL32207, “Special Rules and the Rules Committee,” updated Feb 2024, pp. 22‑24] ↩
  7. [Survey of Activities of the House Committee on Rules, 118th Congress, Interim Report to July 1 2025, p. 32] ↩