A billboard can go up in a stand of woods beside Interstate 485 on Charlotte's east side. In return, most of the trees have to stay. Charlotte City Council approved that trade Monday night, over the objection of the city's own planners.
The 7.6-acre site lies west of I-485, north of Windtree Lane and south of Robinwood Drive. It is outside the city limits but under the city's zoning, and it is zoned for houses. Its owner, Sam's Mart, LLC, asked to rezone it to a manufacturing and logistics district for one purpose: a billboard. The plan the council approved keeps 6.2 acres as tree save, land that must stay wooded. A planner said the conditions "run with the land, not with the current owner." Cutting into the tree save would take a new rezoning.
Council Member Dimple Ajmera, who serves at large, sided with the planners and cast the only no vote. A separate citizen panel, the Planning Commission's Zoning Committee, had recommended approval 6 to 0.
The planners' objection
City planning staff said the problem was policy, not trees. Moving land from a neighborhood designation to manufacturing and logistics on the city's long-range map has "a pretty high bar," a planner told the council, and this request did not clear it. Staff acknowledged that the tree save was "a good benefit."
Ajmera worried about what comes next. "It's not just one billboard here. It is what happens when the next applicant comes forward, asking for the same exception with the same commitment," she said. The planner answered that "petitions don't set a precedent, strictly speaking," because each is judged on its own, though others like it could come.
At the October hearing, two neighbors spoke against the petition. One said the sign would be a digital billboard and that approval would invite the same request for other residential parcels along Harrisburg Road.
The state billboard law
Members also asked about a state law that lets billboard companies clear trees along state highway right of way. Planning staff said it would not reach the protected woods: the owner has bound itself to a much smaller clearing area than the up to 500 feet the law allows, and the city controls only the land outside the state's right of way.
The district member's case
Council Member JD Mazuera Arias, whose District 5 is closest to the site, said he had spoken with neighbors next to it and on the other side of the highway. "If we vote no tonight, a developer can buy it tomorrow and clear cut every single tree on that lot by right with zero community input," he said.
Asked how often a petitioner sets aside that much of a site for trees, the planner said, "It's certainly unusual," and added that no petition in the planner's time with the city had committed so large a share of a site.
Council Member Joi Mayo of District 3 said she would back the district member. So did Council Member Victoria Watlington, who serves at large. She said that "while I absolutely take the policy point, it appears that we got to the right end."
