People who live beside Interstate 77 South are getting a group to advise on how at least $300 million the state promised their neighborhoods is spent. The city is taking applications for seats on it. The application period closes Nov. 30.
The Charlotte City Council created the group Monday, Nov. 16, then tied 5 to 5 over who gets to pick its members. Mayor Rob Harrington broke the tie against changing the rules.
His vote means three council members will each fill one seat on their own, without a vote of the full council. They are Danté Anderson of District 1, Malcolm Graham of District 2 and Joi Mayo of District 3, the districts the rules call impacted.
The money comes from an agreement the state signed with the city Sept. 22. A day earlier, the council had dropped its opposition to toll lanes on I-77 between the South Carolina line and uptown, a stretch of 11 miles. A preliminary benefits plan attached to the agreement puts $150 million toward decks built over the highway, with crossings and green space on top. The rest goes toward items including a recreation center, housing and small-business programs, environmental work and places to address food insecurity.
The agreement calls for a working group, the one created Monday, to propose the final benefits plan. The council was to create it Nov. 9, but staff pulled the vote because members still had questions.
The rules for filling the seats had changed by Monday's special meeting. The group has 11 community seats. The mayor now fills two, down from three in the Nov. 9 version. The council fills seven, up from six: four by a vote of the full council and three by the district members. The N.C. Department of Transportation names the other two. Three government representatives, two from the city and one from the state, sit with the group without a vote.
The argument over three seats
Council Member Victoria Watlington, an at-large member elected citywide, objected to the district picks. "At-large members represent these very same districts," she said. All council members, she said, "particularly those that appear on the ballots of the affected residents, should be weighing in on that decision."
City Attorney Andrea Leslie-Fite told her the district members' choices, like the mayor's appointments, would be reported to the council but not approved by it. The city's boards generally give the mayor a third of the appointments and the full council two-thirds, Leslie-Fite said. The district picks were recommended as an exception because of the project and the history of the area, she said. Whether to adopt them was up to the council.
Council Member Dimple Ajmera, who is also elected citywide, said Watlington "raised a good point." Council Member Reneé Johnson of District 4 said she agreed and suggested a lottery among applicants. In Charlotte, she said, "we know the same folks get appointed to the committees over and over and over again."
After other members had spoken, Watlington moved to have the full council vote on all seven seats, with one seat still set aside for each of the three districts.
Anderson, one of the three district members, said the group was not a place "where the entire city should have a larger voice." The people who will live next to the highway and "smell it, see it, wake up to it every day," she said, "should have direct input."
The vote was a show of hands. Five went up for Watlington's change and five against. "I vote against that amendment to break the tie," Harrington said.
No chair, no vice chair
Minutes earlier, Watlington had won a different change. The rules, on Nov. 9 and again Monday, had the mayor name the group's chair and vice chair. She moved to let the group choose its own. Anderson said she was not sure it needed either, and Graham said a facilitator will run the meetings, so "having a chair or vice chair may not even be necessary." Watlington changed her motion to drop both positions, and it passed 9 to 1.
Seats for people outside the corridor
Up to two seats can go to people who live anywhere in Charlotte: one of the mayor's picks and one of the state's. Council Member LaWana Mayfield, also elected citywide, questioned why any seat should be open to people who live away from the highway. "I can care less about what someone that's out in Ballantyne or South Park" has to say about it, she said.
Leslie-Fite said the option leaves room for someone with technical expertise, for instance, who does not live or work there. Filling a seat that way is optional, she said. "The at-large isn't a must."
What the group can and cannot do
The group advises the city and the state. It cannot commit public money, sign contracts or commit the city or the state to anything. Watlington asked staff to say so plainly. "I don't want any residents watching thinking that this is going to be some kind of decision-making body," she said.
The group will propose a final benefits plan and recommend how projects are defined and delivered, Rebecca Hefner of the city manager's office told the council. It will not choose who gets money. "They will not make specific selections," she said.
The state will ask developers for proposals to build the lanes. If the city and the state do not agree on the group's plan, the preliminary plan already attached to the agreement goes into the state's final request instead, Hefner said. The group's plan is due 45 days before the state issues that request, she said. The agreement does not say when that will be.
How to apply
People can apply by Nov. 30, when the application period closes under the council's resolution.
Under the selection process, all 11 community members must live in Charlotte. At least six must live along the highway or in the neighborhoods around it. Up to four can be business owners, faith leaders or leaders of academic institutions there. Terms run two years.
The group is to meet about once a month, in public. The state's Community Engagement Center at 1023 West Morehead Street is the proposed first location.
Under the resolution, the city clerk's office is to compile and distribute the applications Dec. 3. Appointments start Dec. 7.
