Charlotte's new transit authority starts running CATS itself on Jan. 1, but the city would keep providing support services, from fleet services to the 311 call center, for six more months. Some of the trustees who must approve that plan are uneasy about it.
Three committees of the Metropolitan Public Transportation Authority, or MPTA, backed the plan on Wednesday, Nov. 18. Its stated aim, in the recommendation they endorsed, is to "continue service to the community as it is today," with no break in service for riders.
Trustee David Longo, vice chair of the Operations and Safety Committee, who called himself "a bit of an airplane geek," asked whether the board had reached V1, the speed past which a pilot no longer has the runway to stop. "So I have no choice as a trustee to say anything but yes," he said.
"We're ready to take off," answered Carolyn Flowers, one of the authority's two transition co-directors.
Longo kept going. Trustees had been asking for about a year whether there was enough time, he said. "We're essentially skipping things on the pre-flight checklist from a board perspective." Later in the same remarks he added, "I trust you, and I trust the committee structure. But this is just uncomfortable."
Trustee Cameron Pruette, who joined online, said he shared "Vice Chair Longo's uneasiness." The full board's Dec. 9 vote, he said, "needs to be a yes vote." On the finance committee, Trustee Matthew Walt said "we have to fly a little bit blind" but backed the plan.
Each committee recommended the approach by voice vote, and no trustee was heard voting no. The committees endorsed a strategy; the agreements themselves are still drafts.
Two agreements instead of five
The authority took legal control of CATS on July 1 under state law and has had the city keep running it since. On Jan. 1, the city employees who work for CATS are to become authority employees.
Staff call the six months a "bridge." One agreement would keep the city providing the services it gives CATS today through June 30, 2027, using the same cost method it has used in the past, the finance committee was told. A second would let the authority keep using the Blue Line light rail and other property still in the city's name.
Those services number 45 to 47, said James Cass, an outside lawyer for the authority from the firm Robinson Bradshaw. At times the authority had said as many as five agreements could cover them, and city lawyers described three to a council committee on Nov. 2. Now, Cass said, there are two.
As the authority hires its own staff, brings in a contractor or signs a longer deal with the city, each service comes off the bridge agreement. The authority could not order the city to do more than it has done in the past, Cass said.
Ned Curran, who chairs the Finance and Audit Committee, said putting a price on every service would mean budgeting "where you're trying to count who's got what light bulbs." Talks with the city, he said, had reached the point of "look, we're all just going to keep running this."
The property
Most CATS property cannot simply be handed over, because federal grants or city borrowing helped pay for it. Its net book value is about $1.35 billion, and an early count puts about 90% of that value under federal grant rules or city debt, according to the committee packets.
One part got easier over the weekend before the meetings. "We just heard from FTA over the weekend that they can now allow us to transfer those assets even though the grants aren't closed," Flowers said, referring to the Federal Transit Administration. Property with no strings attached is expected to move "sometime in the first quarter or so of 2027," Cass said.
Property that secures city debt will have to stay with the city "for some extended period of time," Cass said. More than $250 million is still owed on that debt, which runs to 2048, CATS Chief Financial Officer Chad Howell told the finance committee.
The votes ahead
City Council gets an overview of the drafts Monday, Nov. 23, according to the council's agenda. The authority's Executive Committee is scheduled to take them up Dec. 2, according to the committee packets (Operations and Safety, Finance and Audit). The full board is scheduled to vote Dec. 9, the vote Pruette said "needs to be a yes vote," and the council Dec. 14.
